Its not contravertial Flor, I just dont happen to believe in the death penalty per se because of cases like the one posted by the OP - I would refer you to Pilgram's statement that if, god forbid, you found yourself accused and wrongly convicted and faced the death penalty for a crime that you didnt commit, would you willing go to your death knowing that you were an innocent man??

This is arguably the positon that this guy in Georgia found himself in and in the case that we are discussing, I felt that there was certainly enough doubt to justify a retrial and not kill him and to hell with the consequences.