I was blamed for hijacking some other thread and here we are discussing of flashing lights, kicking the balls, respect for woman etc etc when the question posed by OP is "What do you think, did he deserve this punishment or not?"... so just not be ridiculed of hijacking again... IMO he shouldn't have been strictly going by the law, which is emotionless and the state should compensate him and the doc who prepared the faulty report be suspended for 1 year.