Both offers dont look very good for a person with 17 yrs experience including gulf Experience. Cost of living is much higher than in Oman.

If you are planning to live here without your family, you might spend QR.2000/- excluding rent/accommodation…..with little or no entertainments. Still you got 5K balance. Negotiate little more on your Basic….maybe a couple of thousands more.

http://www.qatarliving.com/answers/cost-of-living/how-much-should-i-expe...