Rough Justice/Contempt of Court
Dear all,
A couple of recent court reports have left me wondering if Qatari justice is all it might be.
In the first case a young driver was convicted of killing a 12 year old Egyptian boy whilst speeding. He was given a three month suspended sentence, and a short driving ban (I think only one month). Blood money was payable but that will be handled by the insurance company. What sort of deterrent is that to all the crazy drivers on Doha's roads who put lives at risk every time they turn the ignition key? The defendant didn't even bother to turn up for trial which shows utter contempt for the court, and more importantly to the young victim and his family.
The article stated that the driver would have a period to appeal against the sentence FROM THE TIME THAT HE BECOMES AWARE OF THE VERDICT. It's astonishing that he can be granted that leeway when he didn't do the court the favour of turning up to hear its ruling. Where I come from, failing to turn up for trial is a criminal offence which can carry a long jail sentence.
In the second case, reported in today's Gulf Times, a man convicted of drink-driving was fined just QR 3000. He was banned for a month...not for being drunk at the wheel but for bumping into the car in front. Again not much of a deterrent is it? He also failed to show up for his trial and was spared the lash BECAUSE HE WASN'T IN COURT TO CONFESS TO DRINKING ALCOHOL. So that's alright then. Don't go to court, don't face the punishment (note: I do not support corporal punishment...it's the principle that concerns me).
So, what do you think? Are the courts too soft on the criminal whilst failing to protect and provide justice for the victims?
But if you are an expat and you are convicted of drink-driving, you are going to jail for sure, after which you will be deported. You'll probably also incur a heavy fine.
well its obvious innit? the majority of the natives are stupid, and they have no respect for other people. especially the males. females are much better. it is their country, bt we work for them and if it weren't for us they'd still be riding horses. i have such hate for these people particularly the young men. i would most definitely treat them like shit, if they ever come to my country. i might even consider breaking their legs!!
There also was a lengthy article today in The Peninsula about the Labor Law not being implemented concerning the six hours of working time during Ramadan.
The sad fact is that many countries do not regard "vehicular homicide" as murder. The charge is usually reckless or dangerous driving. Hence the sentences are low.
This seems to be the case in Qatar also!
I agree with you 100% stork, way too soft on criminals here, laws are poorly enforced.