Wow, I had no idea there is no public access to the beach! Very interesting, but in that case its not really important to me. I have gotten in touch with some friends of mine, the W and Intercon might be the best option as it is closer to where they live...although the Intercon does not have a gym! I'm leaning towards the W at the higher end of my search, and going to look for lower cost options, thanks so much Qatarisun all your advice has been welcome!

How long did you stay in Doha during that visit? How much longer after that visit did you decide to live in Doha, wondering if you were sold shortly after arrival! haha